Being in the academy during this period has been incredibly challenging. Teaching and learning during Covid, the pressure to shift the academic mission towards specific social justice goals, and the increasing incivility have all added new stresses to our lives. For those of us deeply involved in the culture wars, such as myself, facing censorship, de-platforming, and even separation has made the situation even more difficult.
Despite facing these challenges, I am fortunate that my institutions, Duke University and Duke Law School, have supported my work. However, there were moments when the situation was so dire that I considered stepping away. This should not be the reality.
No single person or political group should have the power to silence important discussions in a university, department, or classroom. Academic freedom, intellectual engagement, and civil discourse are crucial aspects of a modern university’s role in society, regardless of political affiliations.
Here are two excerpts from Chapter Eight of On Sex and Gender, titled The Left’s Assault on Free Expression, that shed light on my experiences with censorship and the broader questions surrounding the university’s mission:
Reflecting on my personal experiences with censorship and de-platforming, I encountered a significant shift in 2020, particularly during a talk at UCLA where protestors disrupted the event and labeled me as a ‘TERF’ and a ‘transphobe’.
Similarly, at Duke, a petition called for my dismissal and the cancellation of a volume of essays I was co-editing, showcasing the challenges to academic freedom and professional norms.
Free speech is essential for our liberty, equality, and competitiveness. Blocking the exchange of ideas leads to oppression and dissent, diminishing opportunities for all. The university’s version of free speech, academic freedom, allows for the exploration of diverse perspectives and ideas, a cornerstone of a modern university’s purpose.
While universities have substantive commitments, they must also uphold academic freedom and allow for the discussion of challenging topics. Upholding these principles is crucial for fostering a diverse and inclusive academic environment.
As we navigate the challenges of free speech and academic freedom, it is important to reaffirm our commitment to engaging in difficult discussions respectfully and thoroughly within the university setting.
