Jessica Tisch, the newly appointed police commissioner of New York City, stands out from her predecessors. Unlike them, she has never served as a police officer. What sets her apart even more is her affluent background and Ivy League education, providing her with a plethora of career opportunities.
As New Yorkers hope for a reduction in crime and restoration of public order under her leadership, it is worth acknowledging that Tisch’s chosen path was once common among the wealthy: government service.
While it may be too early to predict her success at One Police Plaza, it is commendable that she has chosen to serve, a rarity among those with her level of privilege.
In the past, the American elite viewed government service as a responsibility, particularly evident during World War II when prominent individuals volunteered their expertise for nominal pay to contribute to the war effort.
These “dollar-a-year men” included industry leaders like William Knudsen, Henry Kaiser, and Albert Kahn, who oversaw critical wartime production efforts without seeking financial gain.
Similarly, figures like the Roosevelts, Bushes, Michael Bloomberg, and Donald Trump have pursued public service despite their wealth, distinguishing themselves from those motivated by financial gain.
Tisch’s background and values make it unlikely for her to be involved in scandals like her predecessor, Edward Caban.
In the past, top graduates from prestigious universities embraced the idea of serving the nation, as exemplified by mottos like Princeton’s “In the nation’s service and service of humanity.” However, recent trends show a decline in graduates choosing government careers.
Today, a small percentage of graduates from institutions like Princeton and Harvard’s Kennedy School opt for government roles, with many gravitating towards finance, consulting, and activism instead.
Despite having numerous opportunities outside of government, Tisch, with her elite education and family background, has chosen to serve the public, recognizing the moral obligation of the wealthy to benefit society.
Her family’s history of public service, including her grandfather’s role as a police chaplain, has likely influenced her decision to pursue a career in law enforcement.
While there may be elements of personal satisfaction and prestige in her role, Tisch understands the responsibility that comes with the position, including being held accountable for public safety.
Having capable and competent individuals like Tisch in government is essential for addressing critical issues such as law enforcement, national defense, emergency management, and public health.
Time will tell how Tisch performs as police commissioner, but her commitment to public service deserves recognition and respect.
Howard Husock is an American Enterprise Institute senior fellow and the author of “The Poor Side of Town — And Why We Need It.”
